Arteze

Insights / Article

Contract review · 4 min read

Five questions every obligation in a contract should answer

Many supplier disputes start with a sentence both sides read differently. Our W4C rule tests each obligation for who, when, what, why and the consequence.

Many supplier disputes do not start with bad faith. They start with a sentence that both sides read differently. "The supplier will provide reasonable support during the transition" sounds clear when the contract is signed. Two years later, the buyer thinks it means a dedicated team for three months, and the supplier thinks it means answering emails when it can.

To avoid this, we test every obligation we draft or review against a simple rule we call W4C. It asks five questions: who, when, what, why, and what is the consequence.

The five questions

  1. Who is responsible? Name the party, and where it matters, the role. "The parties will agree" often means nobody acts.
  2. When must it happen? Give a date, a deadline or a trigger, such as "within ten working days of a request". Without one, there is no point at which the obligation has been missed.
  3. What exactly must be done or delivered? Describe the output in a way that someone else could check, including the format or standard where relevant.
  4. Why does it exist? A short statement of purpose helps both sides interpret the obligation sensibly when circumstances change.
  5. What is the consequence if it is not done? This might be a service credit, a step in the escalation process, a right to withhold payment or, for serious failures, a termination right. An obligation without a consequence is closer to a hope.

An example

Here is the vague sentence from above, rewritten using the rule.

The Supplier shall provide a transition team of at least two named engineers for the 12 weeks following the Exit Date, so that the Replacement Supplier can take over the Services without interruption. The team will attend weekly handover meetings and answer written queries within two working days. If the Supplier does not provide this support, the Customer may withhold up to 20 percent of the final quarterly charges until it is provided.

The numbers will vary from contract to contract. What matters is that both sides can now tell whether the obligation has been met.

Using the rule in your own contracts

You do not need to apply W4C to every line of a contract. Start with the obligations that would hurt most if they failed: service levels, data handling, security, exit and change. Read each one and ask the five questions. Where an answer is missing, that is where a future dispute is most likely to start.

Our contract review service applies this test across your most important agreements and suggests clearer wording where it is needed. If you would like us to look at one contract first, you can request a contract review through the website.

Start the conversation

Want to know whether this applies to your contracts?

The first conversation is free, confidential and comes with no obligation. Bring one contract, one supplier or one question, and leave with a clearer view of where the value is.